AI product planning
Agentic AI vs Generative AI: Which Does Your Product Need?
By Haris Ahmed · Code Huddle · Product engineering guides
Published · Updated
Generative AI creates content such as text, images, or code. Agentic AI uses models and tools to work toward a goal across steps. The ideas overlap: an agent may use a generative model. The useful product question is whether users need an answer, a predictable workflow, or a system that chooses its next action.
What changes when AI can take actions?
A language model can draft a response without changing anything outside the conversation. Add tools and a decision loop, and the system may retrieve records, choose a next step, and request an update. That changes the product’s permission, approval, and recovery requirements.
Anthropic distinguishes predefined workflows from agents that dynamically direct their own tool use. “Agentic” terminology varies across vendors, so describe the actual behavior in your requirements rather than relying on the label.
| Product question | Generative feature | Agentic feature |
|---|---|---|
| What does it produce? | Content or a prediction presented to a user | A task outcome using selected tools and intermediate results |
| Who chooses the next step? | The user or predefined application logic | The model chooses within configured limits |
| What must you verify? | Output quality, sources, latency, and cost | Those checks plus tool actions, permissions, and recovery |
Example: answering a support request versus resolving it
Consider a customer asking to change a delivery address. A generative feature can draft a helpful reply from the support policy. A fixed workflow can check the order state and show an address-change form. An agent could inspect the request, select the order lookup tool, and prepare the appropriate update.
The agent still needs a clear boundary. Require the customer or support operator to confirm the address before a write, and handle orders that have already shipped. This example describes a possible design, not a delivered client result.
Choose the smallest useful implementation
Start with the user’s task. If an answer is sufficient, a retrieval-backed response may be enough. If the steps are known, application logic can coordinate them. Consider an agent when the next step depends on information discovered during execution and a bounded set of tools can complete the task.
- Write three realistic requests and their acceptable outcomes.
- List the systems and permissions each request needs.
- Separate read operations from actions that change something.
- Define when to ask a person, stop, retry, or escalate.
A decision test before choosing an agent
Use the same request to compare three possible designs. For the delivery-address example, the table below is an illustrative planning exercise. Your order rules, available APIs, and approval process determine the actual implementation.
- If every step is known in advance, prototype the fixed workflow first.
- If the model chooses a step, give it only the tools and records that task needs.
- Make the proposed change reviewable before committing it.
- Define a completion signal in the underlying system, such as the confirmed order address.
| Option | Good fit | What remains with the user |
|---|---|---|
| Generative answer | Explain the delivery policy or draft a response | Find the order and make any permitted change |
| Fixed workflow | The system already knows the checks and update sequence | Provide the new address and confirm the proposed change |
| Agent with bounded tools | The next step varies with the request and retrieved records | Approve the final change and resolve cases outside the tools or policy |
Evaluate the whole task, including unsuccessful runs
Measure whether the intended task was completed correctly, not just whether the final response sounded plausible. Include missing records, unavailable APIs, ambiguous instructions, and duplicate requests in the evaluation.
Track the cost and latency of a complete run, including retries and tool calls. Release first to an agreed audience with execution limits, reviewable traces, and a way to pause the workflow. The AI agent service page explains how we scope that work.
Write failure tests alongside the happy path
For the illustrative address-change workflow, test an order that has shipped, two matching orders, an unavailable order API, and a repeated confirmation. Decide what the user should see in each case before development begins.
Keep a reviewable record of the request, tool results, proposed action, approval, and final system state. Set a task budget and a stopping rule. If the approved update cannot be confirmed, return an unresolved status and route it to a person rather than reporting success.